Editor’s note: This is a guest post by [S!MPL]. Learn more about [S!MPL] and their work here.

Jackie Brown (1997) Frame image; copyright: Miramax Films

Car parks and parking structures have been a source of inspiration for filmmakers, photographers and writers.  Yet to the people who use them, they’re not much more than a functional area one would rather leave as quickly as possible. Associations are often negative: too cold, too dark, too stinky and too insecure.

We went out on the streets in The Hague and asked different users how they experienced the parking areas they left their cars in. Two large parking areas were researched:
1. Grote Markt (part of a tramtunnel by OMA); a double height area with a length of approximately  2 km.
2. Lutherse Burgwal; a standard parking tower with many levels (split level concept).

These are the positive findings:

Grote Markt Lutherse Burgwal
  • location close to city center
  • car is safer then on the streets
  • good lighting
  • camera surveillance
  • wide parking spaces
  • relatively clean
  • access close to parking place (many places of access)
  • just a few parking layers but still enough free places (often mentioned that people prefer to park their car in a garage with few layers)
  • only connection in the center between the southern and the north part of the city and the other way around
  •  location close to city center
  •  car is safer then on the streets..

…………………………………………………

.

.

.

These are the negative findings:

Grote Markt Lutherse Burgwal
  • steep stairs
  • just a few elevators
  • no pedestrian zones
  • can’t pass cars, which are waiting for a place
  • still not many people like to park their car here at night (dont’ feel safe “afraid of groups of boys”)
  • at the entrance the difference between outside light and the relative darkness inside of the parking garage is too harsh (a gradual change would be better)
  • high prices and not paying per minute
  • too dark (bad lighting)
  • stinks (not hygienic and clean)
  • bad sign posting
  • small parking places
  • camera surveillance not visible (important for the feeling of safety for the person and over its car).
  • high prices and not paying per minute                       .

We found similar results in our research as in scientific articles on parking garages, most importantly: adequate lighting (1) and visible opportunities for users to escape from the parking garage. Because adequate lighting and prospect (i.e., visibility into an environment that provides few hiding places for potential offenders) decrease the perception of danger in urban public spaces, especially in spaces where low opportunity for escape cannot be altered (e.g., bridges and parking garages).(2)
One of the interesting findings in our small user experience research is that people prefer parking garages with only a few levels instead of the often built parking towers. Even a very long parking garage is preferred over a small parking garage with more levels.

As the ones we’ve visited, car parks don’t usually tickle our imagination and people think of them as functional elements only. Innovative planners and creative designers have come up with new and refreshing ways of approaching car park design.
In HongKong plans are being made for a modern parking tower which houses space for concerts, fashionshows, artexhibitions and filmprojections.
A fun example of wayfinding is the parking garage of the Hotel Puerta America in Madrid.

Parking garage; Designer - Teresa Sapey; Hotel Puerta America, Madrid
Parking garage; Designer – Teresa Sapey; Hotel Puerta America, Madrid

Parking areas like these are not just about user-experience on a basic level (fulfilling needs like safety, recognisability, accessibility and cleanness), their aim lies on a higher level of being an experience on their own. It is important to focus on the needs and wishes of the users of certain parking garages. For example people who go out glamorously dressed to a theater prefer to park their car in a similarly glamorous environment instead of a grey concrete cold parking garage.
Parking could even be taken to a level of functioning as a restorative environment.  Restorative environments provide relief from stress and/or attention fatigue. Restoration is a process that begins to occur when four factors are present in the person-environment interaction:

  1. getting away from one’s usual context,
  2. fascination
  3. extent or immersion
  4. compatibility.(3)

This means that a parking space should become a favorite place to be, an fascinating environment which allows you to forget your daily troubles.
Imagine you can park your car at hut 12 on the Maldives, or on a place with a wonderful view into a garden, or a place with a movie projected on the wall in front of you, or even into a cloud.

Maldives car park; artist impression S!MPL

Parking areas should always aim to answer to the basic requirements of their users. At the same time they have enormous potential to influence our daily experience. Not as dark areas of criminal intent, but a positive surrounding people talk about and want to spent some time.

If you have something to add from your own experience with parking garages, just drop us a line on Twitter.

References

  1. C. Tseng, J. Duane, and F. Hadipriono; (2004) Performance of Campus Parking Garages in Preventing Crime; Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities Volume 18 Issue 1.
  2. A. Blöbaum and M. Hunecke; (2005) Perceived Danger in Urban Public Space: The Impacts of Physical Features on Personal Factors; Environment and Behavior Volume 37 Issue 37
  3. K. Korpela and T. Hartig; (1996) Restorative Qualities of Favorite Places; Journal of Environmental Psychology Volume 16 Issue 3.

One thought on “Parking as an Experience

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s